Auckland [change]

Showers

Max18° Min12°

I'm sick of Gerry Brownlee's carping and moaning

James Robins | View Archive September 13, 2012, 10:53 am
CHRISTCHURCH, NEW ZEALAND - JUNE 23: Earthquake Recovery Minister Gerry Brownlee yawns during the announcement plans for earthquake affected areas of Christchurch at the Art Gallery on June 23, 2011 in Christchurch, New Zealand. The New Zealand government has offered to buy 5000 earthquake-damaged homes at a cost of up to $NZ635 million.

Photo by Martin Hunter/Getty Images © Enlarge photo

What happened New Zealand?

Did you just suddenly forget that 185 people were killed in the 2011 Christchurch earthquake?

Did you suddenly forget that thousands of families are still living on a knife-edge because of government failings and inept indecision from the council?

Did you suddenly forget that vast swathes of cash are being plundered in to ridiculous things like rebuilding the ChristChurch Cathedral?

Talking to a friend a few weeks ago, she mentioned a “detached” feeling I’m sure the rest of the country feels towards the plight of Canterbury residents. As a member of the Christchurch Diaspora myself, now living in Auckland, I can understand it. Almost.

Gerry Brownlee has clearly forgotten all of the above, though.

The Earthquake Recovery Minister said that he was "sick and tired" of the "carping and moaning" from TC3 residents over his lack of empathy or action. According to my former employer The Press, he said “there were 27,000 people in TC3 land and only 10,000 of those were likely to need new foundations.”

Well, heaven forbid that more than 10,000 families, homeowners, business owners and landlords would want something done about their situation promptly and reasonably, and without the foul and inconsiderate tones of Mr Brownlee.

He attempted an apology, but then went on to justify his earlier statement.

This is precisely the kind of willful disregard for duty and disrespect of constituents that I wrote about a few weeks ago, and we ought to expect more of a man in such a powerful role, not just that he carries out his tasks as a minister with the utmost integrity, but that he handles his temper and doesn’t slide in to the curse of the reactionary.

On top of this, the establishment is again sticking it to beleaguered Christchurch residents by funding a $4.9 million, six-part drama series for TV3 on the earthquakes.

As I’ve said before, good money is being spent, or is being dedicated to ridiculous, superfluous, trivial, and arbitrary tasks when real Cantabrians are not getting the support they need.

As Mike Coleman from We Can pointed out, "In terms of good investigative journalism and highlighting the issues of affected communities, we've had none of that. So why not put a couple of million in finding out what's really going on for folk across Christchurch."

NZOA CEO Jane Wrightson says locals will have a ‘big input’ in the shows. Will that input consist of employing Christchurch locals as part of the crew and cast of the production? Heaven knows there are enough qualified and intelligent people without jobs.

These are empty words and empty promises. A drama series, no doubt carrying those fateful and truth-bending words ‘Based On A True Story’, only has one purpose: entertainment, and that’s an affront to the integrity and true grit of Cantabrians.

Show:
Newest First
Oldest First
Top Rated
Most Replies

160 Comments

  1. Hilda01:22pm Monday 15th October 2012 ESTReport Abuse

    `Brownley is a F.... #$%$ and needs dumping.

    Reply
  2. Neil01:06pm Monday 15th October 2012 ESTReport Abuse

    I thought Italy would have been the only place where people where left to live in tents for months, until the churches were rebuilt.

    Reply
  3. Helen11:36am Friday 28th September 2012 ESTReport Abuse

    I find the worst thing about 'the powers that be' in Christchurch is their detachment from the situation. Our house was red stickered after Feb's quake, which means that we would incur a $10K fine if we enter. We are now in a position of having to pay a mortgage, partial rates and insurance on a house we can't live in, whilst also paying rent. Our current rent is $550 per week and we receive $275 per week from the Govt's temp housing allowance, so we have a $1100 per month 'shortfall' to pay. Our insurer is saying we get priority because our house is uninhabitable, however the EQC is holding things up as we have a retaining wall (Port Hills) and the EQC haven't even assessed our damage yet. At this rate, we will be waiting to rebuild for years to come. We are responsible people - had full comprehensive insurance and even had six months worth of emergency money in the bank. We certainly don't have a spare $33K in the bank to keep covering this 'shortfall'. We have used up our contents payout so when we finally get our rebuild, we won't be able to furnish our home, we have borrowed from our parents (who are also waiting for a rebuild on their home). We are desperate. When we hear Mr Brownlee's comments about carpers and moaners - we fit into this category. The powers that be have no sense of urgency and for the first time in my life I can really understand why people go 'postal'.

    Reply
  4. GARY10:33pm Wednesday 26th September 2012 ESTReport Abuse

    We really should not be pushing the poor man, he is so over worked that he has not had the time to answer my question from 18 months ago, must be a real buggar to be so behind (no pun intended)

    Reply
  5. .jeay4nz04:58pm Friday 21st September 2012 ESTReport Abuse

    HELLO YAHOO, WHAT happened to the Drop down section at the top of the page that used to give us The Oldest, The Newest and the Others in-between, Huh, Now one has to fight his / her way through every page to get to the Oldest comments first just to see What is happening and who is bitching about whom in here, COME ON GUYS, GET IT FIXED, PLEASE.

    Reply

Opinion

  • James Robins

    May 15, 2:33 pm
    AP, DOJ, GCSB

    I've joined Twitter. Follow me here: @James_ARobins“Freedom of the Press, if it means anything at all, means the freedom to criticize and oppose” – G...

Yahoo! New Zealand News Preferences

Close

Select your region to see news and weather for your area.