The danger of too much tweeting

By Tech Talks | View Archive May 27th, 2009, 12:13 pm
  • Send
  • Print

I've written in the past about how useful Twitter can be as a news tool as well as a social networking tool. However it also has the potential to cause all kinds of issues.

The tragic case of the death of former boxer Mike Tyson's young daughter is a case in point.

Early this morning I first got a tweet saying that four-year-old Exodus Tyson had died after an accident with a treadmill cord. On first look it passed the 'bullshit' detector - it appeared to be from a fairly reputable organisation and a second tweet from the same source referenced a major news provider.

It also built on the story we ran yesterday afternoon about the initial accident, so was definitely worthy of further investigation.

Within seconds this information was being retweeted all over the place. People were essentially passing on the information without taking a second to try and verify it.

I literally couldn't read the tweets fast enough.

In this case, verification against the source proved impossible. There was nothing on the news provider's website and the only information was coming from people retweeting the original information.

Then people started tweeting their condolences, essentially mini statements of fact that the little girl had died - even though at this point there was not a single piece of evidence that was the case.

A little while later another statement appeared on a random website, this time from a 'hospital insider' stating the little girl had died at around midnight. Again, the link to this website was retweeted and passed on as fact despite there being not a single piece of corrobarating information.

People even started to build on the existing tweets with their own information, including one particularly sick effort which stated as fact the little girl had been strangled by her big brother.

It then got weirder.

The original source for the story deleted their initial tweet which started the whole thing off, instead choosing to leave a tweet which put the blame at the door of the major news provider it was continuing to reference in error.

At that point the only credible conclusion to make was that someone was playing a particularly callous game and didn't have any real information.

And then, it appears, that the little girl actually did die.

Okay, some of you may say that it turned out to be true - but I believe this was more of a coincidence than anything else. It was well known Exodus was in intenstive care and deeply ill and therefore it wasn't a huge jump for people to believe she actually could be dead.

The same happened last week when reports of actor Patrick Swayze's death were promoted without verification.

The latest information I have seems to indicate the tragic death occured around 11.45am when she was taken off life support, casting further doubt as to the veracity of the original reports.

My belief is that Twitter can give a real competitive advantage in the cut-throat world of the media. But it also has the ability to be abused - in this case mostly unwillingly by people just wanting to pass on prayer messages and their positive thoughts.

So next time you see some breaking information on Twitter, take a few seconds to verify it before passing it on - you may be surprised at the results when you do.

Comments

  1. carolynjune View Profile

    The REAL question is: Why are people so quick to write people off?? ... It's like everyone just wants Patrick Swayze to die already, so they can move on to the next tragedy - SICK. If I was terminally ill - I wouldn't tell anyone!

    May 27 04:06 pm
  2. joehoc33 View Profile

    Man! I felt sorry for the 4yrs old Exodus. Where da hell was her guardian or PARENTS at the time of accident!!! Young Kid should always be watched over by a reliable Adult. So young so sad.

    May 27 08:10 pm
  3. haydenjshaw View Profile

    What organisation reported Swayze as dying should be shut down immediately. Who reported it should lose their job and be sued to bankruptcy. Lies that are reported should be punished by imprisonment. Then we might start having people working as reporters that are not fraudsters. There never seems to be an accountability in the media. Yet M Johns loses his job for having an orgy. What a f-cked up world if you ask me

    May 27 08:52 pm
  4. twincreekappaloosas View Profile

    So very sad about Exodus.. However, kids do things like that. Joehoc33, you cant be watching over a 4yo's shoulder 24hrs a day! It's impossible. Kids do go off and play quietly, I know my 4yo does, and yes, I have caught her putting things around her neck too. I always check to see what she is doing periodically. But, it only takes a minute or two for what happened to happen. So tragic. My thoughts to her parents.

    May 28 05:36 am
  5. megs_240891 View Profile

    My opinion of gutter journalists is once again reaffirmed. Half truths not getting all the facts. I always thought they were out there getting their stories,in people,s faces but no they just sit on their asses going through the web looking for stories. What a great job. After Princess Diana's death involving the paparazzi I don,t read a lot of what is put in the newspapers or on TV I saw the bit on yahoo news yesterday but didn,t read it thought once again, sensationalized journalism.

    May 28 08:46 am
  • 1 - 5 of 5 Entries

Post your comment

To post a new comment, you must Sign in first.

News Poll

Do you avoid companies that outsource their call-centre staff?

Do you avoid companies that outsource their call-centre staff?

Vote Now

Opinion

  • Amy Williams

    October 23, 2009, 12:49 pm
    Public-art players and pantsless plonkers

    As the long weekend beckons, it's time to take a light-hearted look at some of this week's quirkier news...

  • Ed's View

    November 11, 2009, 11:34 am
    Is Hone Harawira a racist?

    The Oxford Dictionary defines racism as "1. Belief in the superiority of a particular race; prejudice based on this. 2. Antagonism towards people of other races."Since his expletive laced email tirade Hone Harawira has been called many...

  • Ellie Evans

    November 20, 2009, 5:47 pm
    The most shocking of tales

    Several stories this week merit a special mention in my mind-boggling news blog, but this first one will take some beating. Or shocking.A police officer called to a house in an small Arkansas town saw fit to use his Taser on the house's unruly...

Yahoo!Xtra News Preferences

Close

Select your region to see news and weather for your area.