HS2 map shows where cheaper alternative to scrapped northern leg will go
A proposal to build a cheaper alternative to the scrapped northern section of HS2 has been unveiled - with claims it will be just 15 minutes longer than the initial plans.
A proposal to build a cheaper alternative to the scrapped northern section of HS2 has been unveiled - which it has been claimed will be just 15 minutes longer than the initial plans.
A report commissioned by the mayors of Greater Manchester and the West Midlands found that a proposed 50-mile railway line between Lichfield, Staffordshire in the Midlands and High Legh, Cheshire, would create a new link between the Midlands and the North West.
The coalition of private sector organisations led by former HS2 Ltd chairman Sir David Higgins described the alternative new line, which would connect with the proposed east-west Northern Powerhouse Rail, as a “golden opportunity”.
It comes after prime minister Rishi Sunak cancelled the plan to extend HS2 between the West Midlands and Manchester in October last year amid spiralling costs.
The report found that under the new proposals, journeys between London and Manchester would only be 15 minutes longer than under initial HS2 plans - which would still be 30 minutes quicker than today.
It did not provide an estimated cost of the new project, but said it would be lower than HS2 because of the need to design tracks for lower speeds and using simplified connections with the existing rail network, and said financing should be “maximised from the private sector”, with central and local governments “partnering to fund the balance”.
The consortium found the new line has the potential to deliver “roughly 85% of the benefits of HS2 Phase 2” at 60-75% of the cost.
The HS2 project has been marred by delays, with the high-speed rail project fist given the green-light in 2012. Phase 1 – linking London and Birmingham – is expected to be completed around 2030, at an estimated cost of £66.7bn.
Here, Yahoo News provides a timeline of the controversial project to show how we got to this point.
Recommended reading
America's ambitious high-speed rail plans are putting Britain to shame (The Telegraph)
UK wasting 'tens of billions' on crumbling infrastructure and badly run projects (The Guardian)
Government accused of using 'fag packet' in hotel room to draw up £36bn HS2 replacement plan (CityAM)
2009
The Labour government establishes HS2 Ltd in January to examine the case for a new high-speed rail line. Former prime minister Gordon Brown announces a plan for a north-south high-speed rail project in December, promising to invest £20bn in railway infrastructure.
2010
A consultation on a route for HS2 from London to Birmingham with a Y-shaped section to Manchester and Leeds is published by the Conservative-Liberal Democrat coalition government in December.
2012
Transport secretary Justine Greening announces the government has decided to go ahead with the project, despite concerns over its cost and the environmental impact of construction. Already by this point the project's cost has risen to £32.7bn.
2013
In June, the government says the cost of the project had risen to around £53bn. This is partly due to costs associated with a new route, including a tunnel through the Chilterns.
2014
The Supreme Court rejects outstanding appeals by opponents of the rail scheme in January.
2015
The budget is raised once again to £55.7bn in November.
2016
The National Audit Office warns in June that HS2 is under financial strain and could be delayed by a year. Simon Kirby resigns as HS2 Ltd chief executive in September.
2017
HS2 Ltd accepts it was a "serious error" to make £1.76m of unauthorised redundancy payments to staff. That same month, the government confirms 16 newly-built homes on the Shimmer housing estate in Mexborough, South Yorkshire, would be bulldozed to make way for the railway line.
2018
Sir Terry Morgan resigns as chairman of HS2 Ltd amid criticism over his role as chairman of Crossrail, which is delayed and over budget.
2019
The Conservatives commission a review in August into whether and how HS2 should continue, led by former HS2 Ltd chairman Douglas Oakervee. The following month, a report by HS2 chairman Allan Cook says the railway may not be completed until 2040 and could cost £88bn.
Read more: HS2 'has turned our rural village into a hellish building site'
2020
The Oakervee review is widely leaked in January, revealing that HS2 could cost up to £106bn. The report still concludes that "on balance" the project should continue. Then-prime minister Boris Johnson gives HS2 the go-ahead in February, re-setting the so-called funding envelope.
Phase 1 is set at £44.6bn (at 2019 prices), while the estimated cost for the full network is revised to a range of £72bn to £98bn. HS2 gives formal approval for companies to begin construction of Phase 1 in April.
Watch: ‘The forgotten North’: Public react to HS2 fund reallocation
In May, a report by the all-party public accounts committee (PAC) accuses the Department for Transport of not being upfront about delays and costs. It says the project has gone "badly off course" and questioned why HS2 Ltd's chief executive, Mark Thurston, was paid a £46,000 bonus on top of his £605,350 salary.
Construction formally begins on the Birmingham leg of the project in September, with Johnson marking the milestone at an event in Solihull, West Midlands.
2021
Environmentalists dig a network of tunnels in London's Euston Square Gardens in January, prompting a complex operation by authorities to remove them.
In March, the government says anti-HS2 protests and the COVID-19 pandemic have contributed to the project facing additional "cost pressures" of £800m. In June, the Tories' shock by-election defeat to the Liberal Democrats in the Buckinghamshire constituency of Chesham and Amersham is partly attributed to concerns over HS2.
By October, the government says HS2's cost pressures have risen to "around £1.3bn", partly due to delays completing preparatory work, approving designs and securing planning consents. The following month, transport secretary Grant Shapps scraps the eastern link from Birmingham to Leeds, with the route being "safeguarded" in case a future government decides to fund it.
Watch: HS2 contractors say they won't stop digging to Euston despite setbacks from government
2022
Shapps points to a "landmark moment" as the bill for Phase 2, extending the project to Manchester, is laid in parliament in January.
In May, construction of the Colne Valley Viaduct begins. It will be the UK's longest railway bridge, stretching for 2.1 miles above a series of lakes and waterways just outside north-west London. In October, levelling up secretary Michael Gove suggests capital investment for HS2 would be reviewed, but chancellor Jeremy Hunt subsequently backs the project.
2023
In March, the government says construction for the Birmingham to Crewe leg is to be delayed by two years. Meanwhile, work at Euston is paused as costs have risen to £4.8bn, well over the budget of £2.6bn. It means that until at least the 2040s, the route will stop at Old Oak Common, six miles away from the central London station.
In June, the government says services between Birmingham Curzon Street and Old Oak Common are expected to begin from 2029 to 2033, with the Manchester leg up and running between 2035 and 2041.
Read more: HS2 'intimidated landowners over compensation claims after contact with MP'
The following month, the Infrastructure and Projects Authority (IPA) watchdog rates HS2 as "unachievable" and says the whole plan may need to be "reassessed", but the government remains committed to the project.
In October, prime minister Sunak confirms he is scrapping the northern Birmingham to Manchester route. He says "every single penny" saved would go towards transport projects in the North and Midlands, citing £36bn in investment.
2024
In January, planning protections safeguarding land on the abandoned Birmingham to Crewe route ends, the Department for Transport confirms. Meanwhile, Andy Burnham and Andy Street attempt to bring the Birmingham to Manchester route back from the dead.
In July, plans for new train services between London and Manchester are unveiled following the cancellation of HS2’s northern leg. Operator London Northwestern Railway is seeking permission to extend its existing services – which run between the capital and Crewe – to Manchester Victoria via the West Midlands. It is seeking to use the same track space on the West Coast Main Line that Virgin Trains and Lumo have announced open access bids for.
In September, a report from a coalition of private sector organisations led by former HS2 Ltd chairman Sir David Higgins, commissioned by the mayors of Greater Manchester and the West Midlands, proposed an alternative 50-mile railway line to connect the Midlands and the North West.
According to the proposals, journeys between London and Manchester would only be 15 minutes longer than under initial HS2 plans - which would still be 30 minutes quicker than today, and the project would be cheaper than HS2.