With Kimmel off while preparing for his infant son Billy’s second heart surgery, it was up to the NBA legend guest host to ask parents to fake steal their children’s treats and film their reactions.
O’Neal then played out some of the funniest responses to the joke, which Kimmel has been pulling since 2011. “I’m sorry, but that’s hilarious,” O’Neal said afterwards.
To participate, upload a video to YouTube with the title “Hey Jimmy Kimmel, I Told My Kids I Ate All Their Halloween Candy.”
The show will broadcast the best clips later this week.
Check out the full segment above.
This article originally appeared on HuffPost.