“The 360” shows you diverse perspectives on the day’s top stories and debates.
Since the start of the pandemic, the United States has experienced a troubling trend of even though Americans have been driving less. An estimated 38,680 people died in crashes in 2020, a significant spike from the previous year, which the government has mostly attributed to unsafe driving on wide-open roads during last year’s extended lockdown periods.
That surge continued in the first half of 2021, despite traffic patterns picking up toward pre-COVID levels. If that trend holds through the rest of the year, 2021 will be the deadliest year on America’s highways since the mid-2000s.
The high rate of traffic deaths in the U.S. is not entirely tied to the pandemic. Though the from their peak in the 1970s — when more than 56,000 people died in crashes in a single year — traffic fatalities have been gradually ticking upwards over the past decade. During that same period, some of America’s peer nations in Europe and East Asia have cut their rate of deadly crashes in half. By certain measures, the U.S. has the of any developed country.
Why there’s debate
The National Transportation Safety Agency says that reckless driving is the primary reason for the spike in traffic deaths. “All of us must work together to stop aggressive, dangerous driving and help prevent fatal crashes,” the agency’s acting administrator said. Many have also called for an increase in traffic enforcement to help rein in unsafe drivers.
But many safety experts argue that the U.S. needs to stop blaming all crashes on individuals. The NTSA has said that are caused by human error. That attitude, critics argue, ignores the ways the nation can make roads less dangerous through safety-minded design and better laws. Those methods include lower speed limits, incentives for people to buy smaller vehicles, roads designed to prevent high-speed driving and better infrastructure for alternative transportation options.
Buttigieg recently announced that the Transportation Department is developing a new national roadway safety strategy that experts say may lead to a pivot away from the conventional wisdom about crashes being a result of human error and include recommendations for systemic changes to reduce traffic deaths. That report is expected early next year.
Curbing unsafe driving speeds is the best way to save lives
“Controlling speeds on roads is the most important goal of any car safety strategy. There are two main ways to do that: change the physical design of the road with ‘traffic calming’ measures that encourage slower driving, like narrowing lanes and adding speed bumps, or change the legal speed limit, which is easier and inexpensive but less effective.” — Marina Bolotnikova,
We must stop blaming individuals for the ways our systems make roads unsafe
“What we need most is a reexamination of how carmakers, traffic engineers, and community members—as well as the traveling public—together bear responsibility for saving some of the thousands of lives lost annually on American roadways. Blaming human error alone is convenient, but it places all Americans in greater danger.” — David Zipper,
The U.S. must stop treating all of these unnecessary deaths as part of everyday life
Individuals do have a major part to play in reducing road deaths
“While there is no one causative factor, the reckless behavior is likely the confluence of increased drug and alcohol use, lack of safety constraints (like seat belts and texting), and greater opportunities for speeding and reckless driving given still fewer cars on the road, which is linked to feelings of liberation.” — Health researcher Karl Minges to
There needs to be better, more aggressive enforcement of traffic safety laws
Crashes are one of many reasons the U.S. needs to reduce its reliance on cars
“Driving creates an atmosphere of perpetual fear for everyone outside of the car. It undermines urban design, which ends up encouraging more driving instead of encouraging cycling, walking or riding the bus. It prevents non-drivers from the freedom to live the lives they want to live. It deprives kids of the opportunity to travel freely and gain independence.” — Gersh Kuntzman,
Americans’ entire attitude toward driving needs to change
“We often call these terrible tragedies ‘accidents,’ as though they were acts of God or random events that could not be avoided. They are not. ... They are all too often the result of a mind-set that continues to prioritize cars over human life. It permits drivers to ignore known hazards and make excuse after excuse for rule-breaking — until something fatal occurs. It almost seems as if we love cars more than ourselves.” — Helaine Olen,
Is there a topic you’d like to see covered in “The 360”? Send your suggestions to email@example.com.
Photo illustration: Yahoo News; photos: Getty Images