Anthony Sulla-Heffinger
AEW Double or Nothing 2024 results, grades and analysis: Mercedes Moné wins TBS Championship in AEW in-ring debut
Moné captured her first championship in the company and MJF made his surprise return
AEW "Double or Nothing" took place Sunday night at the MGM Grand in Las Vegas. "Double or Nothing" was the first signature event AEW had after its inception in 2019. Sunday, the company celebrated the five-year anniversary of the event with a loaded, 12-match card that featured seven championships at stake.
The main card was bookended by the two most entertaining contests of the night.
The first saw Will Ospreay win his first championship in AEW, as he continues to showcase his immense talent amid a meteoric rise in the company. After that match, AEW's biggest homegrown star, MJF, made his surprise return and announced that he's resigned with Tony Khan's company for the foreseeable future.
On the women's side, Mercedes Moné had her first match since debuting last March, picking up a victory to dethrone Willow Nightingale as the TBS Champion.
The night closed with a chaotic Anarchy in the Arena match, where The Elite defeated Team AEW.
AEW Double or Nothing results:
Deonna Purrazzo def. Thunder Rosa by pinfall in 10:13.
Grade: B
Best spot: Purrazzo grabbing the rope to win
Analysis: Purrazzo and Rosa put on a solid opening match, with contrasting styles and personas meshing nicely. The Virtuosa working heel and using underhanded tactics to pick up a victory over Rosa suggests we’re likely to see a third contest between these two.
The Acclaimed def. Cage of Agony by pinfall in 11:40.
Grade: B
Best spot: Brian Cage’s second-rope suplex
Analysis: The Acclaimed walked out with a win and could be in line for a shot at the trios championship in the near future. Beyond that, there were some fun moments between Billy Gunn and Cage as well as some impressive offense from Cage of Agony even in a losing effort.
Will Ospreay def. Roderick Strong by pinfall in 17:46 to win the International Championship.
Grade: A
Best spot: Ospreay not using the Tiger Driver ‘91
Is Ospreay going to use the Tiger Driver?!
Order #AEWDoN on PPV right now!
💻: https://t.co/MpmTCyHt8n
🔗: https://t.co/GTkwK7GBIn@WillOspreay | @RoderickStrong | @TheDonCallis pic.twitter.com/KZfEqQgMN5— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) May 27, 2024
Analysis: Ospreay and Strong earned the highest grade of the night, and deservedly so. Ospreay’s ascent in AEW continues as he manages to steal the show every time he steps into the ring. It was a smart move to have Don Callis suggest Ospreay use the move he retired just last month and then have him not follow through, but still win. It’ll be interesting to see what happens with the Undisputed Kingdom, especially with MJF’s surprise return coming at the expense of Adam Cole after this contest.
Bang Bang Gang def. Death Triangle by pinfall in 12:22 to retain the Undisputed Trios Championship.
Grade: B+
Best spot: Lucha Bros. offense in closing moments
ROCK HARD Juice Robinson from out of nowhere!
Order #AEWDoN on PPV right now!
💻: https://t.co/MpmTCyHt8n
🔗: https://t.co/GTkwK7GBIn@JayWhiteNZ | @theaustingunn | @coltengunn | @BASTARDPAC | @PENTAELZEROM | @ReyFenixMx pic.twitter.com/eBvY7nWOin— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) May 27, 2024
Analysis: Death Triangle returning to the trios picture was very welcome and they looked to have not missed a beat despite going longer than a year without competing together. The involvement of Juice Robinson in the finish allows Bang Bang Gang to stay on top of the division while also protecting Death Triangle. An ongoing feud between these teams may be in the cards and after this match I don’t think anyone would complain if it is.
'Timeless' Toni Storm def. Serena Deeb by pinfall in 15:42 to retain the AEW Women's World Championship.
Grade: B
Best spot: Mariah May/Luther fighting over throwing in the towel
Is Mariah May trying to throw in the towel??
Order #AEWDoN on PPV right now!
: https://t.co/MpmTCyHt8n
: https://t.co/GTkwK7GBIn@MariahMayx | @SerenaDeeb pic.twitter.com/7jm8b4edg8— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) May 27, 2024
Analysis: The biggest takeaway from this match is the cracks showing in the Luther/Mariah May/Storm triangle in the wake of the towel debacle during the contest. Deeb had a strong showing and pushed the champion to her limits, so while she may be out of this title picture, she could make for a solid first opponent for new TBS Champion Mercedes Moné. Storm’s “Timeless” character is one of the best in AEW at the moment, so keeping the championship with her is the right move for the foreseeable future.
Orange Cassidy def. Trent Beretta by pinfall in 13:46.
Grade: B+
Best spot: Beretta’s Gotch piledriver on the apron
SPIKED on the apron!
Order #AEWDoN on PPV right now!
💻: https://t.co/MpmTCyHt8n
🔗: https://t.co/GTkwK7GBIn@OrangeCassidy | @trentylocks pic.twitter.com/fWJ4jgRlIz— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) May 27, 2024
Analysis: A frustrated Beretta stormed out of the arena after losing to Orange Cassidy, so his future direction isn’t exactly clear, but he likely remains a heel. This was a different Cassidy match than we’re used to seeing, as it was very hard-hitting and personal. Cassidy remains a major fan favorite and another win at a major AEW show continues to raise his profile.
Chris Jericho def. Katsuyori Shibata and Hook in 12:42 to retain his FTW Championship.
Grade: B
Best spot: Hook suplexing Big Bill through a table
HOOK sends Big Bill crashing through the table!
Order #AEWDoN on PPV right now!
💻: https://t.co/MpmTCyHt8n
🔗: https://t.co/GTkwK7GBIn@IAmJericho | @730hook | @K_Shibata2022 pic.twitter.com/6SnlqzHA0e— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) May 27, 2024
Analysis: There were plenty of fun spots in this match and Jericho took an absolute beating at times. Hook looked strong throughout the match and didn’t take the pinfall in the triple threat. Even afterwards as he stalked Jericho and took out security he was presented as a destructive force. We’re going to see him regain the FTW Championship from Jericho sooner rather than later.
Jon Moxley def. Konosuke Takeshita in 17:26.
Grade: B
Best spot: Takeshita focusing on Moxley's arm at the start
GANGREL IS HERE TO EVEN THE ODDS!
Order #AEWDoN on PPV right now!
💻: https://t.co/MpmTCyHt8n
🔗: https://t.co/GTkwK7GBIn@RatedRCope | @Gangrel13 | @MalakaiBlxck | @SNM_Buddy | @BrodyXKing pic.twitter.com/44ORLd4EKc— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) May 27, 2024
Analysis: Moxley sold an arm injury for the duration of this match, which helped showcase Takeshita’s ruthlessness and precision at times. Moxley overcoming that to deny Takeshita in the IWGP Heavyweight Championship eliminator leaves him looking like an overwhelmingly tough and strong champion. He has a title defense early next month and should he survive, will sniff around the main-event picture for Forbidden Door at the end of June.
Adam Copeland def. Malakai Black by submission in 20:20 to retain the TNT Championship.
Grade: A-
Best spot: Gangrel’s surprise appearance
GANGREL IS HERE TO EVEN THE ODDS!
Order #AEWDoN on PPV right now!
💻: https://t.co/MpmTCyHt8n
🔗: https://t.co/GTkwK7GBIn@RatedRCope | @Gangrel13 | @MalakaiBlxck | @SNM_Buddy | @BrodyXKing pic.twitter.com/44ORLd4EKc— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) May 27, 2024
Analysis: From a physical standpoint, this match was brutal, with blood being introduced less than 90 seconds into it. From a storytelling standpoint, it was nothing short of compelling. A barbed wire, steel cage match certainly has the potential to take things a step too far, but Black and Copeland masterfully walked the line during this match. The surprise appearance of Gangrel was a nice touch as Copeland tapped into something he hasn’t in a long time. Copeland grabbing back his wedding ring and exiting to his normal music likely signifies the end of this brief character change.
Mercedes Moné def. Willow Nightingale by pinfall in 18:01 to win the TBS Championship.
Grade: A-
Best spot: Nightingale’s gut-wrench powerbomb onto the apron
The spine of Moné crushed on the ring apron!
Order #AEWDoN on PPV right now!
💻: https://t.co/MpmTCyHt8n
🔗: https://t.co/GTkwK7GBIn@willowwrestles | @MercedesVarnado pic.twitter.com/YDC3liZJtk— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) May 27, 2024
Analysis: Moné and Nightingale have great chemistry in the ring together and this match had the crowd more hyped than any other besides the Anarchy in the Arena. The two women told an excellent story, with callbacks to their match last year in NJPW and there was even subtle character development in the sense that Nightingale charged head-first into several scenarios that Moné was able to capitalize on — something she’ll learn as she gains more experience. Moné winning the championship unlocks a host of new possibilities and the betrayal of Kris Statlander and Stokely Hathaway sets up Nightingale’s next feud.
Swerve Strickland def. Christian Cage by pinfall in 24:52 to retain the AEW World Championship.
Grade: B+
Best spot: Strickland’s backflip kick
SWERVE WANTS TO FLY!
Order #AEWDoN on PPV right now!
💻: https://t.co/MpmTCyHt8n
🔗: https://t.co/GTkwK7GBIn@swerveconfident | @Christian4Peeps pic.twitter.com/liKfHGwE10— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) May 27, 2024
Analysis: Cage and Strickland put on an entertaining match, even though the outcome was never really a question. This was a much-needed match for Strickland’s development as AEW World Champion as he regained his swagger and overcame what was essentially a four-on-one at one point during the match. Cage remains a main-event level talent, but this match fell just a shade below what we’ve come to expect from AEW.
The Elite defeated Team AEW in 30:21.
Grade: A
Best spot: “The Final Countdown”
There could not be a more appropriate song as Anarchy unfolds here at the @MGMGrand!
Order #AEWDoN on PPV right now!
💻: https://t.co/MpmTCyHt8n
🔗: https://t.co/GTkwK7GBIn@youngbucks | @rainmakerxokada@bryandanielson | @daxftr | @cashwheelerftr pic.twitter.com/Zw05vB4p6S— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) May 27, 2024
Analysis: There were plenty of remarkable moments during this match which, depending on your preference, was among the best of the night. The Elite winning here, and Jack Perry being carried out by the EVP Young Bucks continues their hostile takeover of AEW while also building the “Scapegoat” into an even bigger star. Darby Allin took an absurd level of damage and I do think stringing him up was probably a bit too far, but overall it was an entertaining match to close the show.
For full match breakdown and analysis, check out the recaps from our live coverage below.
LIVE COVERAGE IS OVER16 updates