The '30 Rock' alum previously stumped Consuelos four months prior over whether she was a Guinness World Records titleholder or a runner-up for Miss New Jersey Teen USA
Donning an "I Stumped Mark" T-shirt signaling her previous victory, Krakowski presented the Riverdale alum with two statements that he had to determine which were true or false. If she stumped him a second time, she would win another Kelly and Mark mug as well as the "I Stumped Mark Again" T-shirt, which co-host Kelly Ripa noted is "very rare" and is only the "third one in existence."
With 60 seconds on the clock, Krakowski presented Consuelos with two different stories about her life. One tale involved the Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt alum seeing the musical Rent on stage 20 times while the other centered around her competing in a New Jersey ice skating competition that led to her participating in another contest in New York's Lake Placid.
Since Krakowski managed to keep her composure the entire time, Consuelos was completely stumped by the end. "God, you're good! You're good," he said.
Keeping her past as a child actor in mind, Consuelos accepted the tale about her seeing Rent two dozen times as truth. But to his dismay, he answered incorrectly and Krakowski said: "Give me the shirt!"
At that, Consuelous playfully got up from his seat with a smile on his face and walked off the show's set. Meanwhile, Ripa stood up and gave Krakowski a big hug. He then returned to hug her as well.
"All right, Jane," Consuelos said upon returning. "That doesn't count against my record?"
Krakowski previously stumped Consuelos four months ago. During that game, Consuelos had to determine whether she was a Guinness World Records title holder for being a part of the world's biggest tap dance line or a previous runner-up in the Miss New Jersey Teen USA competition. He picked the pageantry contest and lost.
Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.
Live with Kelly and Mark airs weekdays (check local listings).
For more People news, make sure to sign up for our newsletter!
Read the original article on People.