Yahoo Life Shopping
Why you can trust us

We independently evaluate the products we review. When you buy via links on our site, we may receive compensation. Read more about how we vet products and deals.

‘Stayed on when I kissed my man’: This Maybelline lip color rivals Taylor Swift's red lipstick — and it’s on sale for $9

Want that Taylor Swift red lip classic thing that you like? This universally flattering liquid formula will get you there.

Got a blank space in your makeup bag? Fill it with a superstar product. There are few things as iconic as Taylor Swift and her red lipstick. Over the years she's worn a variety of cherry-colored lips (that classic thing that you like...), but her latest fave has captured the attention of every Swiftie and non-Swiftie alike. Vibrant, long-lasting and basically kiss-proof, Pat McGrath Labs Liquilust Legendary Wear Lipstick in Elson 4 is incredible but ... sold out right now. It's also on the pricier side at $34. No worries, though, because Swifties have found a terrific alternative: Maybelline's Super Stay Vinyl Ink Longwear Liquid Lipcolor in Wicked. And it just so happens to be on sale for $9. Talk about good karma!

Incredibly shiny, this Tay Tay-like lipstick will ensure your perfect pout lasts all day long. 

$9 at Amazon
Explore more purchase options
$10 at Walmart$13 at Ulta Beauty

Taylor can surely snap up $34 Pat McGrath lipsticks anytime she wants. But for the rest of us? We say there's no need to overpay when an almost identical, way more affordable product exists. Its typical price of $13 is already great, but throw in a 30%-off discount and you've got Taylor-made lips for less than a Chipotle bowl.

It's seriously long-lasting — up to 16 hours without smudging or color transfer, according to the brand. And that's key for a liquid lipstick. The sleek vinyl-like color it delivers is just stunning.

Not only is the vegan formula top-notch, this cool-toned shade looks good on pretty much everyone — even those who are hesitant to rock a red lip. It's a great color that's not too shocking, so it'll make you look like you were born with red lips, just like our girl Taylor.

Taylor Swift performs at Melbourne Cricket Ground on February 16, 2024 in Melbourne, Australia wearing a sparkly pink and blue bodysuit.
Dazzle like Tay Tay ... without too much pay-pay. (Getty)

With more than 31,000 flawless five-star ratings, the Maybelline Super Stay Vinyl Ink Longwear Liquid Lipcolor clearly has its own powerful fandom beyond Swifties.

Raved a shopper: "I’m not a fan of lip products because no matter what, they all dry out my lips and make them very chapped no matter how I prep them first. Definitely not a red-lip girl either. However, I wanted something to complete my Taylor Swift concert look, but I also didn’t want to re-apply. This shade was perfect for my skin tone and looked pretty. I drank water and it stayed on."

"I finally found something that works with the texture of my lips and the dryness. Omg it stayed on when I kissed my man, [leaving] no lipstick on him or anything I drank or ate," wrote another thrilled Amazon shopper. "As a 67-year-old woman who is young for her age, I love it." They went on to say: "I feel gorgeous and sexy with this lipstick on, like in the Trace Adkins song 'Hot Mama'."

A final Amazon shopper gave it a five-star approval, mentioning that the trick is to shake it before swiping it on: "I wore this for my friend's wedding. It stayed on for the whole wedding ceremony and reception. Didn't smudge at all even after eating dinner. Didn’t come off on my glass at all either. It stayed exactly as it was when I applied it for well over 12 hours without me having to reapply or touch up at all."

While shoppers love how vibrant the lipstick is, some reviewers noted that it's a little too ... attractive even after the formula dries down. "This is very sticky. I applied it as per the instructions and 15 minutes later still had very sticky lips," one shopper described.

On a related note, customers point out that the lipstick does stay — but almost too well. Unlike most lipsticks that you can just swipe off, one reviewer said that "it takes soap, water, and some scrubbing to wash off." So just make sure to whip out your best makeup remover whenever you wear this!

This Wicked shade looks the most like Taylor's favored Elson 4 from Pat McGrath but the formula comes in 24 other colors.

$9 at Amazon
Explore more purchase options
$10 at Walmart$13 at Ulta Beauty

The reviews quoted above reflect the most recent versions at the time of publication.

If you have Amazon Prime, you’ll get free shipping, of course. Not yet a member? No problem. You can sign up for your free 30-day trial here. (And by the way, those without Prime still get free shipping on orders of $25 or more.)

  • Bellisso Biotin Shampoo and Conditioner Set

    Save $10
  • Nature Well Clinical Retinol Advanced Moisture Cream

    Save $10 with coupon
  • Crest 3D Whitestrips Professional Effects Plus, 24 Treatments

  • Dermora Golden Glow Under-Eye Patches, 15 Pairs

    Save $3 with coupon